top of page

Sociological Theory SA502

Topic #1 History of Sociological Thought

Week #1.  Introduction to Social Science & Theory:  Why Study Sociology and Social Theory? 

This section will give you a general overview of the history of different theories. We will also focus on  understanding their "domain assumptions" & how theories compare – we will explore the basic differences between the three major theories we will also talk about Max Weber,  We will discuss some of the theories in more detail  as the course unfolds.

 

This section also asks you to think critically about science and scientific method. Science is not TRUE or FAKE. Pure social science should be an attempt to understand what is happening in the world. Social scientists should be strive to be "objective" and consider observable facts. But we can never be completely free of our paradigms or   “perspectives”. The Sociology of Knowledge is a paradigm that suggests that Sociology and what social scientist do is no different from what anyone else does in society. Therefore Sociology should be reflective and also turn a critical lens on its own beliefs and practices.  

When reviewing this information remember that all theories have underlying beliefs and ideas.  

 

Theories are made up of concepts, belief systems, methods....

Writing on Glass

Assignments

Assignment #1: Quiz (Domain Assumptions and comparing theories) 100 points Quiz posted to canvas.

Discussion Questions

Discussion Question #1:  Introduce yourself to the class and tell what experience you have with Sociology. What do you see as the benefits of Sociology as a discipline? Is the field of sociology still relevant in contemporary society why or why not?  How do you think Sociology could help you with your current career or future career choice.

(100 points) 400-500 words

Readings

The readings for this week are listed below. When ever possible I linked directly to an online resource. I also posted these readings and links to canvas. 

computer head.png

In sociology, a paradigm is a broad framework or model that shapes how researchers understand and study society. It’s like a lens through which social reality is viewed — guiding what questions are asked, what methods are used, and how findings are interpreted. ChatGPT

A theory in sociology is a systematic explanation of how and why social phenomena occur. It’s more than a guess — it’s a structured set of ideas that helps sociologists interpret patterns in human behavior and social life. ChatGPT

Copilot_20260521_204816.png

The lectures for this week are posted to Canvas and will be available the first day of class. I decided not to post them to the webpage now. You will find the lectures on Canvas.

Below are a few points below I want you to remember when you review the course lectures for Topic #1.

Like this image below theorists look at the same social world and see something different. What do you see in the image below?

The-optical-illusion-The-Young-Girl-Old-

There are many many different Sociological theories this is just a partial list of the most popular ones. 

 

Each of these theories have their own domain assumptions and ideas on how the social world works and how and why people behave the way they do.

  • Functionalism

  • Conflict Theory

  • Symbolic Interaction

  • Critical Theory

  • Ethnomethodology 

  • Phenomenology

  • Dramaturgy

  • Rational Choice Theory 

  • Exchange Theory

  • Feminist Theory 

  • Queer Theory

  • Structural Theory 

  • World Systems Theory

  • Strain Theory

  • Critical Race Theory

  • Etc…

Thomas Kuhn- studied how science changes – he found that scientist were not really that objective. As with all humans, scientist held paradigms which constrained  and influenced their work.... and that they held on to their paradigms very tightly and were reluctant to change until the proof of the new paradigm was overwhelming. This video below does an excellent job of explaining Kuhn's idea of how science changes. 

thomas-kuhn.jpg

Even if you are not aware of it you also have a paradign or belief systems about how the world works. For example do you believe the a criminal offender is a product of their environment or a person that makes bad choices? Do you think people can really "change" things in the social world or do you think that the system influences what we do?

H.O.M.E

All social research/theories have underlying Domain Assumptions 

 

In their 1979 Burrell and Morgan noted that all research had basic "domain assumptions" that influence how they interpreted the world. This is a simplification but there are a few fundamental questions that all theories have a perspective on regardless of focus. A good way to remember these ideas is with the acronym HOME

 

  • Human Nature –What is the nature of human nature  - Is man an actor/creator  or observer?

  • Ontology – What is the nature of Reality? 

Does the world exist outside the individual  -  Objective Reality – Structuralist

    • Theories: functionalism, conflict theory, structuralism

    • Look for natural laws of human behavior

    • Positivism – applying the scientific method to the study of man  (A. Comte)

Does the world exist within the individuals perceptions  – Subjective Reality - Humanist

    • Theories, symbolic interaction, social psychology, role theory, exchange theory

    • Look at subjective meanings, perceptions, interpretations

  • Methodology – What is the best method to find out about the world?

  • Epistemology – What is valid knowledge?

  • Other questions to consider

    • What is the view of society? 

    • What is the level of analysis

    • What is the view of the individual?

    • What is the view of the social order? 

    • What is the view of social change?

Topic #1 Video Links

The following videos introduce you to the major ideas related to Sociological theory. They do an excellent job of explaining the ideas and concepts in your Topic #1 readings. 

Assignment - Critical Thinking Exercise

I was doom scrolling one day and came across this idea called the Cookout Theory. This theory trys to explain changes in the Black community in the city of Atlanta. I'd like you to do some critical analysis and lets evaluate Cookout Theory and see if it meets the criteria of a viable Sociological theory. 

Copilot_20260511_115142.png

The Black Cookout. 

Understanding “The Cookout Theory”

“The Cookout Theory” is a term that appears in different contexts — from a viral social commentary video to discussions about fast food culture, reality TV alliances, and Black community traditions — but in the most recent and widely shared sense, it refers to a social commentary piece about the “crisis” facing major U.S. cities with large Black populations.

Origin and Meaning

The theory emerged in a 2026 YouTube video essay titled The Cookout Theory Explains the Crisis Happening to Atlanta, New York, Los Angeles, and Other Cities YouTube. The creator frames it as a metaphor for the erosion of Black cultural and economic power in cities that have historically been shaped by marginalized communities of color. These cities — such as Atlanta, New York, Los Angeles, and New Orleans — are described as being “under siege” due to:

  • Gentrification and displacement of long-time residents

  • Loss of Black-owned businesses and cultural institutions

  • Marginalization in political and economic decision-making

The “cookout” metaphor draws from the Black cookout tradition, a long-standing cultural practice of communal gatherings over barbecue, often in public spaces like parks or backyards Essence. Historically, cookouts were a way for African Americans to assert community presence, share food, and build social bonds, especially in the absence of private kitchens Essence. In this context, the “crisis” is likened to the loss of that space — the “cookout” — where Black people could gather freely and without scrutiny.

Cultural Roots

As Essence notes, cookouts evolved from plantation-era traditions and flourished during the Great Migration, becoming a staple of Black urban life Essence. They were spaces of fellowship, resilience, and cultural affirmation, often hosted in public areas due to limited private kitchens. Over time, they became a symbol of Black community strength and belonging.

Why It Matters

The “Cookout Theory” uses this cultural reference to highlight:

  • The loss of safe, inclusive public spaces for Black communities

  • The economic and cultural displacement caused by gentrification

  • The need to reclaim and protect these spaces for future generations

In short, the theory is both a cultural critique and a call to action — urging cities and communities to preserve the “cookout” as a living symbol of Black resilience and unity.

Theory Credit: @Morgan 

Critical Thinking Questions

In a short paper I want you to analize the Cookout Theory.Would you consider Cookout theory a viable sociological or social theory? Why or why not. What is the criteria for calling something a sociological theory. Is it a Social theory as defined by Kenneth Allen below? Are her ideas testable? Does she have related concepts and does she define her concepts? Can you understand her thought processes? Can you determine the domain assumptions of Cookout theory? What paradigm would this theory fit in? Does it have to fit into one of the three big theories, functionalism, conflict theory or Symbolic interaction? Does it have to fit into one of these areas? Is this theory even sociological? Why or why not?  Is this theory testable? 100 points 2-3 pages

A sociological theory is a supposition that intends to consider, analyze, and/or explain objects of social reality from a sociological perspective,[1]: 14  drawing connections between individual concepts in order to organize and substantiate sociological knowledge. Hence, such knowledge is composed of complex theoretical frameworks and methodology. These theories range in scope, from concise, yet thorough, descriptions of a single social process to broad, inconclusive paradigms for analysis and interpretation. Some sociological theories are designed to explain specific aspects of the social world and allow for predictions about future events, while others serve as broad theoretical frameworks that guide further sociological analysis.[2] Dynamic social theory is the hypothesis that institutions and patterns of behaviour are the social science equivalent of theories in the natural sciences because they embody a great deal of knowledge of how society works and act as social models that are replicated or adapted to achieve predictable outcomes.[3][4]

 

Kenneth Allan (2006) distinguishes sociological theory from social theory, in that the former consists of abstract and testable propositions about society, heavily relying on the scientific method which aims for objectivity and to avoid passing value judgments.[6] In contrast, social theory, according to Allan, focuses less on explanation and more on commentary and critique of modern society. As such, social theory is generally closer to continental philosophy insofar as it is less concerned with objectivity and derivation of testable propositions, thus more likely to propose normative judgments.[5]

Sociologist Robert K. Merton (1949) argued that sociological theory deals with social mechanisms, which are essential in exemplifying the 'middle ground' between social law and description.[7]: 43–4  Merton believed these social mechanisms to be "social processes having designated consequences for designated parts of the social structure."[8]

Prominent social theorists include:[5] Jürgen HabermasAnthony GiddensMichel FoucaultDorothy SmithRoberto UngerAlfred SchützJeffrey Alexander, and Jacques Derrida.

There are also prominent scholars who could be seen as being in-between social and sociological theories, such as:[5] Harold GarfinkelHerbert BlumerClaude Lévi-StraussPierre Bourdieu, and Erving Goffman.

 

READ MORE: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sociological_theory 

General  Discipline Timeline 

Here’s a general historical timeline of sociological theory, Sharon — tracing its intellectual roots from Plato’s philosophical foundations to modern sociological paradigms.

Ancient Foundations (c. 400 BCE – 1600 CE)

  • Plato — introduced ideas about the ideal society, justice, and social order in The Republic.

  • Aristotle — emphasized empirical observation and the polis (community) as central to human flourishing.

  • Medieval thought — social order framed through religious hierarchy and divine law (e.g., Augustine, Aquinas).

Early Modern Social Philosophy (1600 – 1800)

  • Thomas Hobbes — viewed society as a contract to escape chaos; foundation for social order theory.

  • John Locke — emphasized rights and consent, influencing liberal social thought.

  • Jean‑Jacques Rousseau — explored inequality and collective will.

  • Auguste Comte — coined sociology (1838); proposed positivism — studying society scientifically.

Classical Sociology (1800 – 1920)

  • ​​Karl Marx — analyzed class conflict and capitalism’s role in shaping society.

  • Émile Durkheim — established sociology as a science; studied social facts and solidarity.

  • Max Weber — explored rationalization, bureaucracy, and meaning in social action.

  • Georg Simmel — focused on micro‑interactions and the forms of social relationships.

Mid‑20th Century Expansion (1920 – 1970)

  • Talcott Parsons — developed structural functionalism, viewing society as a system of interdependent parts.

  • Robert Merton — refined functionalism and introduced strain theory.

  • C. Wright Mills — emphasized power structures and the sociological imagination.

  • Symbolic Interactionism — emerged from the Chicago School, focusing on meaning and everyday interaction.

Late‑20th Century to Present (1970 – Today)

  • ​​Anthony Giddens — proposed structuration theory and analyzed globalization.

  • Pierre Bourdieu — introduced habitus, field, and capital as tools for understanding power and culture.

  • Judith Butler — advanced gender performativity and post‑structuralist thought.

  • Contemporary sociology — integrates intersectionality, globalization, digital society, and environmental sociology.

Summary

From Plato’s ideal society to Giddens’ global modernity, sociological theory evolved from philosophical speculation to empirical science — continually redefining how we understand power, identity, and social change.

Copilot_20260520_094754.png

Let's Talk 🙃

bottom of page